Let's do this for fun! I know that some people have love/hate relationship with this movie. Some think it's an outrageous chick flick, others think it's a very romantic movie. ROP if you like the movie...

So what do you think main synastry aspects be between Noah and Allie? Here is my version.. definately aspects to Mars/Moon/Sun. Pluto/ Venus/ Saturn. Mars conjuct Venus... would like to hear from you! cheers.

Noah seems like an Aries to me. I don't know why.

Allie seems like a Libra. 

I think Allie has Moon in Virgo and Noah has Moon in Scorpio.

And I'll save the rest for other people to pitch in.

I see attracting/repulsing as Pluto, so maybe love/hate would fall there was well.  As for the other planets, saturn to stand the test of time & work involved.  So, like pluto to sun to saturn or maybe even pluto to sun in cappy (with a positive saturn aspect).  I think of Noah as a cappy. 
Angie

I think venus/pluto aspects.  Definately some kind of saturn return towards the end, if I can remember.  

I must be a sap. lol, I loved this movie.  It made me CRY!!! Boo-Hoo crying!!

I love it when couples reunite.  It's very romantic when it happens. 

Morgan, I am with you on this one... I also believe in happy endings and even if it's a movie!  movie made me cry at the end... :)

Music4am, I could totally see Noah as a cappy! Especially the part of the movie when he renovates the house and never loses his focus. And Allie would be a Leo of course!

:) Morgan, don't feel bad, I cried ALL NIGHT. 

We were at my parents house for a long weekend and it was coming on tv.  My little sister was like, have you seen this?  You should it's REALLY good (she's a pisces).  I was like oh, ok, I'll watch it.  OMG!!!!  I would never do that to someone!!!  I couldn't stop crying over the whole thing, I kid you not I cried ALL night.  I was also telling my pisces friend about it when we got back home.  She's a HUGE fan of this author (guy that wrote the book the movie was based on).  She gave me like 10 of his books to read.  I read one, cried myself silly over that as well and just gave all the books back to her.  I just can't take it, too much, LOL!

catatonia, that is exactly why I was thinking cappy as well :)  I don't really know what Ali would be, but I'd go along with Leo.  That could work, given her love of his attention throughout the story,
Angie

Thanks everyone for the interesting ideas!